In this scenario, a 67-year-old single individual earning $110,000 annually decides to claim their Social Security benefits at full retirement age. They receive $3,100 per month or about $37,200 per year. After taxes, their net benefit comes to around $2,500 a month, or $30,000 a year. That brings their total gross income to roughly $147,000 annually when combining salary and Social Security payments. Since they’ve reached full retirement age, they can earn as much as they want without any reduction in benefits, but their high income triggers other consequences.

This individual’s financial foundation is solid. They’ve accumulated $215,000 in a traditional 401(k) and contribute an additional $10,500 each year. They also hold $10,000 in a Roth IRA, to which they contribute $8,000 annually. On top of that, they expect to receive a $1,200 monthly pension about $14,400 per year once they fully retire. They’re also working toward paying off all debt before leaving the workforce, which is one of the smartest moves anyone can make before retirement.

However, claiming Social Security while still working at this income level means that up to 85% of their Social Security benefits are taxable. This pushes their provisional income higher, resulting in a greater overall tax burden. In this case, the individual’s federal tax bill could exceed $19,000 annually, driven largely by the combination of salary, benefits, and investment income. On top of that, claiming at 67 instead of waiting until 70 locks in a permanently reduced benefit roughly $9,000 less per year.

The long-term trade-off comes down to timing. By claiming at 67, this person gains immediate income but sacrifices future growth in their monthly benefit. If they had waited until age 70, their monthly benefit would have increased to around $3,844 an extra $744 per month for life. The break-even age, where the total lifetime income would even out between claiming early or waiting, is about 82 and a half. That means if they live well into their 80s or beyond, delaying benefits could ultimately result in tens of thousands of dollars more in lifetime income. However, if they value having more money available today or want to ensure they’re debt-free while still healthy and active claiming now could make emotional and practical sense.

There are also side effects beyond just Social Security itself. A higher income while receiving benefits can raise Medicare premiums due to income-based adjustments, increasing healthcare costs in retirement. These additional expenses should be factored into any decision about when to claim.

The pros of claiming Social Security now include enjoying a strong cash flow, achieving debt freedom sooner, and gaining psychological comfort from having a guaranteed income stream. The cons are the higher taxes, a permanently smaller monthly benefit, and potential longevity risk if you live longer than expected. The right choice depends on your priorities whether that’s maximizing lifetime income or securing immediate financial stability.

Ultimately, there’s no universal answer. The decision should align with your financial goals, health, and desired lifestyle. For some, claiming at 67 provides peace of mind and liquidity when they need it most. For others, waiting until 70 offers the security of a larger monthly check and better protection against outliving their savings.

The key takeaway is that understanding your full financial picture your income sources, tax situation, and long-term needs is essential before making this decision. A personalized retirement plan can clarify your best path forward and help you make an informed choice with confidence. And as always, discussions like this are best shared. If you’ve faced a similar decision or have insights on claiming Social Security while working, share your experiences with others it’s a conversation that benefits everyone planning for retirement.

All writings are for educational and entertainment purposes only and does not provide investment or financial advice of any kind.

The post Should You Claim Social Security While Still Working? Here’s What to Consider appeared first on ROI TV.