20 Smart Payment Options for Service Workers

A woman in a white shirt and black apron stands in a kitchen, smiling and holding a plate with a dessert featuring strawberries on top. — Image Credit: DepositPhotos

Tipping has been a common custom in many service jobs for a long time, but it’s time to think about this practice more carefully and look for fairer options. The current tipping system often makes workers’ incomes uncertain and puts too much pressure on customers to help pay their wages.

The federal minimum wage for tipped workers is only $2.13 per hour. Some states pay more, but most still pay tipped workers much less per hour than other jobs.

Change is needed. Workers should have steady, enough pay that does not depend on customers or business ups and downs. At the same time, customers should not have to feel they must pay extra tips to support worker wages.

This article shares 20 ideas to replace the usual tipping system. These ideas are grouped into those focused on customers, employers, and government rules. Each idea aims to fix problems with the current system and support fair, steady, and respectful wages for service workers.

Starting with Consumer-Side Alternatives, let’s see how customers and businesses can work together to make sure service workers get fair pay.

What do you think about these ideas? Have you seen any of them happen? Please share your thoughts in the comments!

Enforcing Fair Labor Standards

A woman and a man sit across from each other at a table in a cafe, both with coffee cups. The woman has a notebook, and they appear to be engaged in a discussion.

Improving labor laws and making sure current rules are followed can help service workers get fair pay, benefits, and safe working conditions. This means stopping wage theft, making sure workers get paid for overtime, and keeping workplaces safe.

Strict rules for labor protect workers’ rights and make things fair for all businesses. This helps stop abuse and treats all service workers with respect.

Following these rules all the time can also build trust in service jobs and make work better for everyone.

Support for Gig Economy Workers

A delivery person hands a large red insulated bag to a woman while she gives him money. Both individuals are wearing masks. — Image Credit: Pexels

Developing policies that extend benefits and protections to gig economy workers ensures they receive fair compensation for their services. Many service workers now operate in the gig economy, such as ride-share drivers or food delivery workers.

Policies could include minimum wage guarantees, access to benefits, or protections against sudden loss of work. Supporting gig workers acknowledges the changing nature of work in the service industry and ensures these workers aren’t left behind.

It can help create a more stable and sustainable gig economy, benefiting both workers and consumers.

Customer Feedback Systems

A woman in a blue dress is talking to a barista behind the counter at a cafe. The barista is wearing a light blue shirt and smiling. There are menu boards and coffee equipment in the background.

Instead of just using tips, businesses could set up places where customers can give feedback that helps decide wages and bonuses. This way, good service gets rewarded without the ups and downs of tipping.

Customer feedback systems make a clear connection between how well employees work and how they are paid. They also give useful information for businesses to get better and find their best workers.

This method helps build a habit of always improving and keeping customers happy.

Higher Base Salaries

A person hands over a one-dollar bill to another person, who is holding multiple dollar bills, as they discuss things people pay for.

Moving to Employer-Side Alternatives, one of the most straightforward solutions is for employers to pay service workers a living wage. This reduces reliance on tips and provides financial stability for workers.

According to the MIT Living Wage Calculator, the living wage for a single adult in the U.S. varies by location but averages around $25.02 per hour nationally in 2023. This is significantly higher than the current federal minimum wage of $7.25 per hour.

Paying higher base salaries might require businesses to adjust their pricing or operations, but it could lead to better employee retention, higher job satisfaction, and improved service quality.

Loyalty Programs

A waiter in an apron serves a seated woman holding a cup. A bouquet of pink flowers and a pastry are on the table. The establishment prides itself on elegance, even displaying a fancy way to say no tips on credit card at each table.

Many businesses use loyalty programs to get customers to come back. These programs might be made bigger to help service workers by bringing in more business and offering steadier work hours.

Loyalty programs can help customers, businesses, and workers all at the same time. They keep customers returning, which brings steady business and might lead to better pay for workers.

These programs also collect useful information about what customers like, helping businesses adjust their services and possibly earn more money, which could be given to workers.

Transparent Pricing

Imagine walking into a restaurant and seeing menu prices that include the full cost of your meal, including service. This approach eliminates the need for mental calculations and ensures workers receive fair wages without relying on customer discretion.

Recent developments in California, through legislation like SB 478, have emphasized the importance of price transparency in the restaurant sector. This system allows customers to make informed decisions about their spending while providing more stable income for workers.

It also simplifies the dining experience, removing the awkwardness of deciding how much to tip at the end of a meal.

Service Charge Inclusion

A server pours wine at a table for a couple in a restaurant. The table is set with a large seafood platter and drinks.

Some high-end restaurants have already adopted this practice, and it could be more widely implemented. A mandatory service charge added to each bill ensures workers receive a consistent income regardless of individual customer decisions.

Recent report indicates that implementing a service charge can lead to a more stable income for service workers. This approach takes the guesswork out of compensation for both customers and workers.

It also allows businesses to more accurately predict their labor costs and adjust prices accordingly.

Direct Payment to Workers

People making contactless payments with smartphones at a counter, politely navigating ways to say no tips on credit card transactions.

With the growth of digital payment systems, customers can now tip workers straight through apps or other tools. This makes sure tips reach the service worker without the employer getting involved.

Direct payment systems make things clearer and allow customers to choose how their money is shared. They also let workers get quick feedback and thanks for their work.

This way can be very helpful in jobs where workers move between many places or have more than one employer.

Comprehensive Benefits Packages

A person with blonde hair writing on paper at a desk, while another person sits across with an open laptop. — Image Credit: Pexels

Money isn’t the only form of compensation that matters to workers. Offering benefits such as health insurance, retirement plans, and paid leave can significantly enhance workers’ overall compensation and quality of life.

In fact, 43% of employees have said their current benefits packages have kept them in their current role. Comprehensive benefits can make service industry jobs more attractive and sustainable as long-term careers.

They can also help businesses attract and retain skilled workers, reducing turnover costs and improving service quality.

If you like what you are reading, then click like and subscribe to my newsletter. We share tips to waste less time and money.

Performance Bonuses

Two hands exchanging U.S. dollar bills next to a pink electronic device and a notebook on a marble surface. — Image Credit: iStock

Performance-based bonuses give a way to thank employees for great work and to support a strong work culture. This system helps workers keep giving good service because they know their hard work will be noticed and paid for.

These bonuses can be based on different goals, like customer happiness scores, sales goals, or how well work is done. This method shows workers a clear way to earn extra pay by using their skills and work.

It also helps companies find and keep their best workers, which leads to better service for everyone.

Flexible Scheduling

A person with light hair in a bun sits in a chair, holding a white coffee cup, looking to the side thoughtfully. They are wearing a blue shirt and a lanyard. — Image Credit: Pexels

Offering flexible work hours can greatly improve job satisfaction and retention for service workers. Many people choose service industry jobs for their flexibility, and enhancing this aspect can make these positions more attractive.

Flexible scheduling allows workers to better balance their work with personal responsibilities, education, or other commitments. It can also help businesses manage their staffing needs more efficiently, adjusting to busy and slow periods.

This approach shows workers that their employers value their time and personal lives, promoting a more positive work environment.

Recognition Programs

A woman wearing an apron stands at a cash register with her hands on the screen, smiling in a warmly lit setting with colorful wall decor. — Image Credit: Pexels

Making programs that spot and reward great work can help build a good work atmosphere and raise worker spirits. Praise can come in different ways, like employee of the month awards, public compliments, or small bonuses for great work.

These programs let workers know their hard work is seen and valued. They also spark friendly competition and push everyone to do their best.

Giving praise often helps build a culture of thanks at work, leading to happier workers and fewer people leaving.

Minimum Wage Increases

Two men stand facing each other; one in a blue cap and overalls with a lanyard, smiling, while the other, dressed in a plaid shirt, holds and shows photographs or documents to him.

Shifting to Government-Side Alternatives, advocating for higher minimum wage laws ensures all workers receive a fair income regardless of tips. Data from the Economic Policy Institute shows that raising the minimum wage to $15 an hour would benefit over 40 million workers in the U.S.

Higher minimum wages provide a more stable income and reduce reliance on tips. This change would particularly benefit service workers in states with lower costs of living, where tips might not be as generous.

Increased minimum wages can also stimulate local economies as workers have more money to spend.

Education and Training Grants

How To Save Money in College; Girl on Campus — canva.com

Government grants for service workers to get education and training can improve their skills and job chances. These grants might pay for job training, college classes, or professional certificates.

Making education easier to get can help service workers grow in their jobs or move to other fields if they want. This use of funds builds a more skilled workforce, helping both workers and the economy.

Education grants can also draw more people to service jobs, seeing them as a path to better opportunities.

If you like what you are reading, then click like and subscribe to my newsletter. We share tips to waste less time and money.

Employee Ownership Models

Two people sitting at a table in a café, engaging with a laptop. A drink and flowers are on the table. The café has large windows and wooden furniture. — Image Credit: Pexels

Cooperative business models where workers have a stake in the company’s success can transform the typical employer-employee relationship. When workers are part-owners, their interests align more closely with the company’s success.

This model can lead to increased engagement, better decision-making, and a stronger sense of community within the business. Employee-owned companies often see improved productivity and customer satisfaction, as workers are more invested in the company’s performance.

This approach can create a more equitable distribution of profits and give workers a voice in company decisions.

Regular Pay Raises

colleagues meet in conference room at office shake hands

Setting up an organized system for pay raises based on how long workers have been with the company and how well they perform can give employees a clear way to grow in their jobs. This method gives workers a goal to aim for and helps keep skilled staff.

Regular pay raises show employees that their skills and loyalty are appreciated. They also push workers to keep getting better and learning new things.

A clear and open pay raise system can lift spirits and motivate workers, which leads to better service and more happiness at work.

Training and Development Opportunities

Three people collaborate at a desk, two with laptops and one handing over papers. The workspace is scattered with documents, a plant, and a lit candle. They appear engaged in a discussion.

Investing in employee training programs enhances skills and opens doors for career advancement, potentially leading to higher wages over time. These programs can cover technical skills specific to the job, as well as soft skills like customer service and communication.

Training opportunities show workers that their employer is invested in their growth and success. They also benefit the business through improved service quality and increased employee versatility.

Ongoing training can help workers stay engaged with their jobs and adapt to changing industry trends.

Childcare Support

Three children sit on the floor, playing a game with circular cards while an adult watches. The setting appears to be a bright, cozy living room with beige furniture and plants near the window.

Providing affordable childcare can help service workers manage their jobs and family duties better, which can help them keep their jobs longer. Many service jobs have evening or weekend shifts when regular childcare is not open.

Childcare programs backed by the government can help with this problem, making it easier for parents to work in service jobs. This help is especially important for single parents and families with less money.

Having childcare they can count on lets workers do their jobs well without stress about their children, which can improve how well they work.

Universal Healthcare

A doctor wearing a white coat and stethoscope shows a tablet to a seated patient in an office.

Implementing universal health care systems can reduce the financial burden on service workers, allowing them to focus on their jobs without the stress of medical expenses. Many service jobs don’t offer health insurance, leaving workers vulnerable to high healthcare costs.

Universal healthcare would provide a safety net for all workers, regardless of their employment status or hours worked. This system could lead to a healthier workforce overall, with workers more likely to seek preventive care and early treatment for health issues.

It could also reduce employee turnover related to health problems or the need to find jobs with better benefits.

Paid Sick Leave Policies

A working-class individual with curly hair and glasses, wearing a green shirt, holds folders and rests their head on their hand against a white background.

Mandating paid sick leave helps service workers keep their income when they are sick, supporting a healthier workforce. This rule is very important in the service industry, where workers often work closely with the public.

Paid sick leave lets workers stay home when they feel bad without worrying about losing pay. This can stop illnesses from spreading to other workers and customers.

It also tells workers that their health matters, which can make them more happy at work and more loyal to their job.

Tip the Balance

A bartender with glasses and a dark vest stirs a drink at a well-stocked bar. — Image Credit: Pexels

The service industry is ready to improve. The 20 options we talked about give many ways to build a fairer and more steady place for the people who run our restaurants, hotels, and other service jobs.

Making these changes will be hard. It needs effort from businesses, customers, and leaders. But each step toward fairness moves us forward.

Next time you meet a service worker, think about their work life and how it could get better. Small changes in how we think and act can start bigger changes.

Together, we can build a service industry that works well for both workers and customers.

If you like what you just read, then subscribe to my newsletter.

AI was used for light editing, formatting, and readability. But a human (me!) wrote and edited this.

Author

Michael Gregory

Will Think is the founder and owner of WilThink.com. After a long career in finance, he retired early and decided to put his knowledge to work in a different way—by helping others. He is also a dad and an avid runner.

Will is a Chartered Financial Analyst (CFA) with over 20 years of experience in real estate investing. He’s also a published journalist whose writing has appeared on MSN, the Associated Press, and other major outlets.

His content combines real expertise with a clear, no-nonsense style that’s both smart and accessible.

View all posts