Why Cutting Out the Middleman Never Works
“Cut out the middleman” sounds like one of the simplest rules in business. If manufacturers can sell directly to consumers, both sides should theoretically save money while an unnecessary layer of cost disappears. Yet some of the largest and most powerful companies in the modern economy have succeeded precisely because they are middlemen.
Intermediaries now sit between consumers and businesses in payments, logistics, advertising, staffing, finance, online marketplaces, data, and global supply chains. Technology was supposed to eliminate many of them. Instead, it often created a smaller number of much larger intermediaries with enormous amounts of information and bargaining power.
Middlemen Exist Because They Solve Problems
Middlemen are easy to criticize because every additional company in a supply chain appears to add another markup. A product might move from a manufacturer to an importer, distributor, wholesaler, retailer, marketplace, and finally the consumer. Each business takes something along the way.
But those businesses are often providing something in return. Manufacturers may not want to maintain thousands of retail relationships, handle individual customer service requests, manage transportation, absorb inventory risk, or predict demand in hundreds of markets. An intermediary can perform those jobs more efficiently and buffer producers from sudden changes in consumer demand.
That is why removing one middleman can sometimes simply create another. A company that starts selling directly to consumers may suddenly need warehouses, payment processors, advertising platforms, fulfillment companies, returns systems, and customer-service providers. The intermediary has not necessarily disappeared—it has just changed form.
Technology Made the Biggest Middlemen Even Bigger
The internet initially promised to connect buyers and sellers directly. In practice, digital marketplaces created extraordinarily powerful new intermediaries because they could bring millions of buyers and sellers together in one place. The more transactions that pass through a platform, the more valuable that platform can become.
Data adds another advantage. A large intermediary can see what consumers buy, what they search for, when demand changes, which products perform well, and how prices affect behavior. Smaller manufacturers and retailers may only see their own customers, while the platform sitting between thousands of companies can see the entire marketplace.
That information can become an enormous competitive advantage. It allows an intermediary to improve pricing, target customers, negotiate with suppliers, and identify emerging trends faster than businesses with narrower access to market data.
Regulation Can Strengthen the Companies Already in the Middle
Regulation can also unintentionally reinforce the position of large intermediaries. Compliance requirements create expenses involving legal teams, reporting systems, cybersecurity, insurance, licensing, and risk management. Large companies can spread those costs across enormous volumes of transactions, while smaller competitors may struggle to absorb them.
The result can be consolidation. Fewer intermediaries remain, but those that survive become larger and more influential. Scale gives them the ability to negotiate better prices, invest more heavily in technology, collect more data, and potentially influence the regulations governing their industries.
Payment networks illustrate the power of the model. Companies such as Visa and Mastercard occupy a critical position in the transaction between consumers, merchants, and financial institutions. They do not need to manufacture the products being purchased to participate economically in an enormous volume of commerce.
Global Supply Chains Are Full of Hidden Middlemen
The same pattern appears in physical products. A business may believe it is buying directly from a factory through a global marketplace, only to discover that the supposed manufacturer is another trading company or intermediary. White-label manufacturers, sourcing agents, freight companies, customs brokers, distributors, and marketplaces can all become part of the final price paid by consumers.
It can look inefficient, but global trade is complicated. Someone has to identify suppliers, verify quality, arrange financing, move goods across borders, handle customs, store inventory, and make sure products arrive where consumers expect them. Businesses often pay intermediaries because building all of those capabilities internally would be even more expensive.
The real change has therefore not necessarily been the disappearance of middlemen. It has been the concentration of those functions among fewer companies capable of operating at massive scale.
The Middleman Model Extends to Labor
The episode argues that labor markets increasingly operate in a similar way. Staffing companies, outsourcing firms, and large consulting businesses can place themselves between corporations and workers, taking responsibility for recruiting, payroll, compliance, immigration requirements, and employment risk.
It also raises concerns about how some intermediaries use programs such as H-1B visas and offshore staffing. The argument is that corporations can distance themselves from employment and immigration complexity by working through outside firms, while those intermediaries profit from the difference between what clients pay and what workers ultimately receive.
Whether in labor, logistics, payments, or retail, the business model follows a familiar pattern. The intermediary makes itself valuable by managing complexity that the companies on either side would rather avoid.
Fewer Middlemen Can Mean More Powerful Middlemen
The strange outcome of decades spent trying to eliminate intermediaries is that many industries now have fewer middlemen—but the remaining ones are significantly more powerful. Their size creates economies of scale, while their transaction volume provides data that smaller competitors cannot easily reproduce.
That can produce a self-reinforcing cycle. More customers create more data, better data attracts more customers, greater scale reduces operating costs, and the resulting profits can fund technology, acquisitions, and lobbying. Eventually, competing with the intermediary requires far more than simply offering lower prices.
“Cutting out the middleman” therefore sounds much easier than it is. Middlemen exist because modern economies are complicated, and complexity creates opportunities for businesses that can connect buyers, sellers, workers, manufacturers, and financial institutions efficiently. The bigger concern may not be that middlemen exist at all, but that a shrinking number of them increasingly control the infrastructure everyone else depends on.